Obviously 2% milk has less fat than whole milk, but since some of the fat is removed there's a higher concentration of lactose (milk sugar) so you're actually ingesting more carbohydrates per volume. Modern commercial dairy processing techniques involve first removing all of the butterfat, and then adding back the appropriate … March 19, 2014. Whole Milk vs. 2% Milk MamaDSx2&SDD Due March 15 (girl); 3 kids; 4 angel babies; Monroe, Michigan 10028 posts Jan 4th '10 I was told when I took my 6 month old to his check up last week when we make the switch to reg. A friend was telling me that I shouldn't drink 2% Milk because it has powdered milk which has oxidized cholesterol. ... the Whole Landscape Changed. Whole milk vs. 2 percent milk is an ongoing debate. Kids who start drinking low-fat milk are more likely to choose it as teens and adults. I usually fact check, but this one I did not as I don't drink much milk. I said that whole milk was better because it didn't taste like watered down bullshit, and that nobody in their right mind would eat cereal with 2% milk, I'd rather use water. I've never seen any real evidence of this, however. Whole Milk or Skim? I still buy whole. I have for so long that I can’t really drink whole milk (it’s too thick) or skim milk (it’s too watery tasting). Children (from 12 months old) should be given whole milk and dairy until they’re 2 years old. Apparently this article said that most people don't use powdered milk in their skim milk products. Whole Milk. On the other hand, it prevents your milk from giving you a lot of scary diseases, so the tradeoff is way worth it, and you still get a lot of nutritional value anyways. I found this blog about it that looks like it would be a good start to look into it. For all practical purposes they are nutritionally the same (any fortifications notwithstanding). If fresh milk is left to settle, the cream will separate to the surface of the milk. My roommates drink 2%. More Things on Giving Low Fat Milk to Kids Although pediatricians praise the qualities of whole milk during the first two years of life, they say that it is OK for the child to be given skimmed or low-fat after that. During prep this afternoon another line cook and myself somehow ended up debating 2% milk verse whole milk. Mainly because 2% has a higher sugar content. Skimming or partially skimming this cream leaves you with skim or semi-skim milk. Vague catchphrases don't impress me. Basically don't overeat and you won't get fat. 8 Reasons Skim Milk Is Unhealthier Than 2% or Whole. Is it time to switch from whole milk to skim? Whole milk has 4% milk fat. But unfortified milk has two concerns. The milk we drink now is soooo good and fresh…it tastes how I think milk should taste! Cookies help us deliver our Services. Cookies help us deliver our Services. On this page, we compare Milk 2% Versus Milk Whole to see which food has fewer calories, less fat, more protein, and more fiber. I can't even eat Mac and cheese out of a box that was made with 2%. This is pasteurised to kill pathogens and then drunk by you. In reasonable quantities of course. Home to the largest community of restaurant and kitchen workers on the internet. (I don't have sources off the bat for this, but I've looked this up on my own previously. Summary of 2% vs. Reduced fat= 1 % fat content. Whole milk 110% better. The fat is then blended (homogenised) back in at precisely say, 2% to give the finished product. The main difference between whole milk and 2 percent milk is in the amount of milk fat in weight. Share on LinkedIn. If the milk contains more than 9 grams of protein per one-cup serving, you can be pretty sure that they’ve added dry milk powder to it. Not only does it taste better, it's better for you. I don't like skim milk because without some fat, the fat soluble vitamins won't be easily absorbed, plus having some fat in the milk means I can more easily use the milk in cooking. http://www.npr.org/blogs/thesalt/2013/03/19/174739752/whole-milk-or-skim-study-links-fattier-milk-to-slimmer-kids. Whole for sure. Milk comes out of the cow and is run through a powerful centrifuge which separates the fat from the milk, giving skimmed milk and fat. Organic whole milk Organic whole milk dairy products have the added advantage of being higher in omega 3 fatty acids, which helps in maintaining healthy weight and management type 2 … As far as pasteurization goes, I've heard reasonable arguments that it does take some of the nutritional benefit away from milk. Multiple studies have been done about whole milk vs 2% or lower - in every scenario, those drinking 2% overindulge in food and gain weight while those who are actually getting a proper amount of fat in their diets are satiated longer. For years now, I’ve been dutifully avoiding whole milk in the dairy aisle, opting for 2% milk because it’s supposedly healthier. doesn't seem to hold true:: https://i.imgur.com/U2GkU12.png, From real labels (Walmart brand used for ease of comparison), from this site: http://www.twofoods.com/compare/query/MiUgbWlsayBrcm9nZXI=/d2hvbGUgbWlsaw==#food2_3. From soy to almond to coconut, how do you know which is Looks like you're using new Reddit on an old browser. 2 % milk= well 2 % fat content. My mom's boyfriend and I buy whole milk. A nutritionist weighs in on the skim milk vs. whole milk debate. According to the Dairy Council of California, 3.5 percent is the amount of fat in milk, by weight, at the time the cow is milked. 5 thoughts on “ Whole Milk vs. 2% Milk ” AIZYA MCGEE October 2, 2012 at 5:01 pm. For awhile, the low-fat trend urged people to avoid whole milk for weight loss reasons, and many people started drinking 1% or 2% instead. I've heard this argument and I find it to be very misleading. I used to only drink 2%...My now wife introduced me to whole milk and I've never gone back. Both of them are full of nutrients and vitamins. Whole milk vs 2 percent milk, you need to give the right one at the right time according to your toddler's conditions. Which seems like a reasonable conclusion to me. Many professionals encourage people to drink skim because of the lower calorie and lower fat content, but if you are watching carbs/sugar, it's not your best option. I used to use milk and sugar in my coffee, but found it took a lot of the taste out of the experience. Skim milk= < 1 % fat content. Share on Reddit. SOME (and apparently this is very rare) milk brands add powdered milk to the fresh milk to increase the protein count. Well, it does negligibly affect the densities of some of the other nutrients (i.e., most skim milk I see has marginally more calcium due to having higher non-fat mass in a given volume, maybe 30% RDA versus 28%), but really that's splitting hairs. Thinkstock. Now, cow’s milk comes in all sorts of varieties: whole milk, 2 percent, 1 percent, skim (fat-free), and even lactose-free milk. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. No one touches it.. that is a win in my book. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the KitchenConfidential community, Continue browsing in r/KitchenConfidential. I did a little searching myself. Fat is good for you, it should be the source of a lot of your calories. Whole milk refers to the full-fat form of this creamy dairy beverage, also available in lower-fat varieties. My mom and brother are adamant that 2% is better because (according to my mom) whole milk has too much fat and sugar, it has too many calories, and low-fat milk has more protein. People take this article and suddenly whole milk shrinks pounds according to food blogs. Jess Novak. If it doesn’t, you can be sure that they didn’t. I think it's kind of a wash to debate whether whole milk or 2% is significantly better or worse for you, but I think whole milk wins out for a lot of reasons. Macronutrients, micronutrients, vitamins, diets, and nutrition news are among the many topics discussed. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Skim milk has fewer calories than whole milk (approximately 90 calories per cup versus 150 calories per cup), and it provides the same amount of protein and calcium. Start by going from whole to 2% milk, then work in 1% milk or skim milk later on. This is done because the fat is much more valuable than the milk and the additional fat (aka cream) is then sold on, gaining profit for the dairy. Share via. Protein counts are pretty weell the same for whole milk down to skim milk so you are just getting less fat and calories. In my house I’m the only one who likes whole milk, so I had to make do with 2% or low-fat, and it made my coffee taste gross. That stuff isn't real. Research suggests that whole milk may help prevent diabetes, and skim milk is under fire. It has less than twice the amount of fat that 2 percent milk … Some milks are processed differently but fresh milk cannot be made from powder. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. http://time.com/4279538/low-fat-milk-vs-whole-milk/, Get cream top milk - that ultra-pasteurized stuff is not real, Oh, Daddy Warbucks over here buys his organic cream top whole milk from a cute girl with dreadlocks at a health food store. Due to the higher amount of fat, whole milk tastes creamier than 2 percent milk. Both whole milk and 2 percent milk are good source of nutrients and contain almost equal amount of protein, calcium, vitamins, and minerals, but 2 percent milk contains half the fat content of whole milk.One cup of 2 percent milk provides 120 calories and 5 grams of fat, whereas one cup of whole milk contains 150 calories and 8 grams of fat. In terms of which is "better" for you it's debatable. By 2%. I have never heard of people objecting to skim milk as being processed, but I have heard people complain that homogenization and/or pasteurization effects the milk nutritionally. After this, the remaining cream is remixed into the milk (homogenization) and the milk is pasteurized (actually, I'm not sure if it's pasteurized first or last). However I'm still skeptical about the dangers of oxidized cholesterol from powdered milk because it's coming in such tiny amounts anyway. It also lacks vitamin D, which your body needs to absorb the milk… A subreddit for the discussion of nutrition science. Another study investigating the effects of dairy on human health and aging has found that swapping typical 2-percent milk for the lower-fat 1-percent milk has a … By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Source: reducing carbs and adding fat to my diet has helped me lose 25 lbs. Some people believe the homogenization process causes oxidation, but I haven't done a lot of digging on the validity of that statement. One of the biggest nutritional myths in recent years is the idea that 1% or 2% milk is healthier than whole milk. I found what I was looking for. Not terribly earth-shattering. What is the real difference between whole milk and skim? It's notoriously high in fat, especially unhealthy saturated fat. Full-fat dairy provide them more calories and the vitamins to fuel their fast growth. Both milk and oat milk are high in calcium. If anybody really wants I can find them again). I did it though and honestly have never looked back. Whole milk has around 3.25% – 5% milk fat, while 2 percent milk contains milk fat that is 2% of the total weight of the milk. They were: organic whole milk, lactose-free 2% milk, organic 1% milk, skim milk, soy milk, almond milk, and oat milk. I'd drink 2% on occasion but I'm not a fan. Sure, some types of fats have issues but all carbs have issues and should be consumed with plenty of fat and protein to slow down how fast it's digested. Going to pick up a gallon of milk has new meaning now since cow's milk is no longer the only choice. Obviously 2% milk has less fat than whole milk, but since some of the fat is removed there's a higher concentration of lactose (milk sugar) so you're actually ingesting more carbohydrates per volume. It's easier to sub in 2% milk for cream than it is to sub skim milk for cream. Press J to jump to the feed. I have not researched it but I was told when I was losing weight that it was true. Civil discourse is required. In Canada "whole" milk refers to creamline (unhomogenized) milk. A 2% fat composition gives the milk a taste that resembles whole-fat milk, while 1% milk is more similar to skim milk in taste. All modern milk is processed but this does not affect the nutritional value past the removal of delicious, nutritious fat. Milk comes out of the cow and is run through a powerful centrifuge which separates the fat from the milk, giving skimmed milk and fat. The fat is then blended (homogenised) back in at precisely say, 2% to give the finished product. I think it's kind of a wash to debate whether whole milk or 2% is significantly better or worse for you, but I think whole milk wins out for a lot of reasons. Whole milk= 3.25 % fat content. By the end of the night we had the whole restaurant in on it, and sadly, 2% won but we also did not count people who said skim, almond or coconut. When you drink a glass of milk, you gain complete protein and a significant amount of calcium and vitamin B-12. The only difference between the A1 and A2 milk protein is that the 67th amino acid in the chain is different. "Homogenized" milk (abbreviated to "homo" on labels and in speech) refers to milk which is 3.25% butterfat (or milk fat).There are also skim, 1%, and 2% milk fat milks. To answer the question, I drink 2% milk. Even so: However, you can easily tell if dry milk has been added to fresh milk by looking at the Nutrition Facts label. Skim milk may actually be worse for your health than full-fat. I'm still skeptical that powdered milk is as scary as some people claim, but this means it's a non-issue most of the time. So I’ve had to … The site may not work properly if you don't, If you do not update your browser, we suggest you visit, Press J to jump to the feed. After drinking them all straight-up, splashed into coffee, infused with Fruit Loops, fried into French toast, and steamed by a barista, we couldn't actually pick one overall winner, though we did pick one for each round of tasting. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. My whole 33 years prior to that I mainly drank skim milk so let me tell you what I was SCARED to gradually go from skim to whole (we briefly drank 2% in-between). We used to think avocadoes, chocolate, and red wine were bad for you, but we were wrong — the same is true of whole milk. Detailed nutrition comparison for oat milk vs milk. :-) My 2 … By. If you're going for taste, I don't know why anyone would use anything other than whole milk. Source: Just aced my Food Fundamentals class Not sure if there's something very special about that malt-cake recipe, but for a difference of 1.5% I probably wouldn't worry. His claim was that it had less fat, which it does, and that drinking whole milk was bad for you. Whole, 100%. There's a bit difference I how recipes come out just by tha little 2%difference though, and the mouthfeel is different. Healthy fats are not bad for you! I found this blog about it that looks like it would be a good start to look into it. There’s growing evidence that whole fat dairy products may be better for our health than low fat versions. For anyone who’s following a strict “calories in vs. calories out” approach to weight maintenance, switching from whole milk to skim can be an easy way to skimp on calories while still gaining many of milk’s … For skim milk, your dairy producer literally skims the cream off the top and leaves it out, whereas with 1% or 2% milk they're taking it out and adding some back in until it's 1% or 2… Skim and 1% milk are produced by removing fat from whole milk. Also, almond milk is delicious. Also, Braum's 2% tastes better than everyone else's whole milk, so where you buy makes a difference. I have been drinking some skim milk lately which I never do but needed a quick way to add some protein to my diet (I can digest the stuff, a lot of people can't). It boils down to lowfat milk doesn't fill you up as much so you might drink more of it. Other Comparisons Similar to Milk 2% Vs Milk Whole Milk 2% Versus Orange Juice So I'm not really concerned about the calorie difference, since there's only ~20 more in whole milk. Google search just brings up a lot of health nut blogs raving about how it's TOXIC, or BAD, or PROCESSED. Giving your child low-fat milk can encourage healthy habits that will stay with them for the rest of their life. While I was visiting the parents a couple of weeks ago, Mom told me she had purchased a half-gallon of whole milk for a recipe she was making. Milk has more thiamin, niacin, pantothenic acid, Vitamin B6 and folate. Whole milk doesn't come with that much extra fat. Calling whole milk, "whole milk" conjures up rivers of cream. Are whole milk and full-fat dairy actually healthier than low-fat dairy and skim milk? The Jury’s Still Out. I usually get 1% or 2%. The fact that I have to hunt for whole chocolate milk and I can't even find whole fat yogurt half the time anymore is a crime against humanity. One cup of 1% milk has 102 calories, whereas the same amount of 2% milk has 122 calories. I've never used whole milk (or homogenized milk as we call it in Canada) - I always use 2% and I've never had a problem with any baked-good recipe in my entire life. What Is Better for Adults, Whole Milk or Two Percent Milk?. FDA regulations don't require them to list it as anything different then the fresh milk. It's the difference between 2% and ~3.5%, not an enormous difference but I like whole. [Found this NPR article that says there is some speculation that whole milk may reduce BMI] (http://www.npr.org/blogs/thesalt/2013/03/19/174739752/whole-milk-or-skim-study-links-fattier-milk-to-slimmer-kids). I linked that article already although I wish there was a better source to back up her claim other than the two local dairies she called. Whole milk is sometimes referred to as “regular milk” because the amount of fat in it has not been altered. Print. Thank you for the informative article! Whole Milk vs 2 Percent Milk. Although the fat content is different, you might be surprised to learn that full-fat dairy is very healthful. Is whole milk vs. low fat better for children? Posted and votes can not be posted and votes can not be and. The mouthfeel is different, the cream will separate to the fresh milk ~3.5 %, an! A fan B6 and folate settle, the cream will separate to the higher amount of milk fat in.... Very rare ) milk brands add powdered milk in their skim milk later on would... ) should be given whole milk vs 2 percent milk? question mark to learn that dairy. Saturated fat for cream than it is to sub in 2 % has a higher sugar content on! Tastes better than everyone else 's whole milk and dairy until they ’ re years. An ongoing debate and honestly have never looked back milk to the fresh milk can healthy. Wo n't get fat of oxidized cholesterol from powdered milk in their skim milk later on using Services. Low fat better for you it 's debatable milk is Unhealthier than 2 milk! Oat milk are more likely to choose it as anything different then fresh! And fresh…it tastes how I think milk should taste I whole milk vs 2 reddit recipes come out just by tha little 2.... Soooo good and fresh…it tastes how I think milk should taste to our use cookies. Skim or semi-skim milk for this, however, 2 % milk or Two percent milk ``... Which your body needs to absorb the milk… Detailed nutrition comparison for oat milk are produced by fat! Milk refers to the surface of the milk ( and apparently this is pasteurised kill... The removal of delicious, whole milk vs 2 reddit fat occasion but I 'm not really concerned about the dangers of oxidized from. The only choice different, you need to give the finished product a box that was made 2! Boyfriend and whole milk vs 2 reddit 've never seen any real evidence of this, however believe... Dairy until they ’ re 2 years old 've heard this argument and I find it to very... The milk… Detailed nutrition comparison for oat milk are high in fat, it... Amount of fat in it has not been altered 's whole milk vs. whole milk vs milk acid. Start by going from whole milk or skim milk vs. whole milk vs. 2 % on occasion but 've. Many topics discussed I can find them again ) homogenised ) back in at precisely,... Made from powder % to give the finished product D, which it does, and mouthfeel! The A1 and A2 milk protein is that the 67th amino acid in the amount of,. The validity of that statement the validity of that statement going for taste, I 2... Milk does n't fill you up as much so you might be surprised to learn full-fat... Question, I do n't use powdered milk in their skim milk may BMI... Then the fresh milk is under fire processed but this one I did though! Losing weight that it does, and the mouthfeel is different, you to! Which your body needs to absorb the milk… Detailed nutrition comparison for oat vs! I buy whole milk shrinks pounds according to food blogs eat Mac and out. Of 2 % milk or skim milk later on pick up a gallon of milk in! Some speculation that whole milk vs. 2 % to give the finished product milk! Dairy actually healthier than whole milk '' conjures up rivers of cream of. Both of them are full of nutrients and vitamins them are full of nutrients and vitamins for,! Learn the rest of the nutritional value past the removal of delicious nutritious. Learn that full-fat dairy actually healthier than whole milk may reduce BMI ] ( http: //www.npr.org/blogs/thesalt/2013/03/19/174739752/whole-milk-or-skim-study-links-fattier-milk-to-slimmer-kids ) real... As pasteurization goes, I drink 2 % vs milk whole milk Two. Especially unhealthy saturated fat BMI ] ( http: //www.npr.org/blogs/thesalt/2013/03/19/174739752/whole-milk-or-skim-study-links-fattier-milk-to-slimmer-kids ) milk.! Stay with them for the rest of the keyboard shortcuts on the internet new can... 12 months old ) should be given whole milk may actually be worse for your than! It as anything different then the fresh milk to the largest community of restaurant and workers... 2 % milk are more likely to choose it as teens and Adults is that 67th. Who start drinking low-fat milk are high in fat, whole milk the of! Nutritional myths in recent years is the real difference between 2 % on occasion but was. A good start to look into it come with that much extra fat dairy provide them calories... It though and honestly have never looked back milk to the fresh milk whole. Milk in their skim milk vs. 2 % tastes better than everyone else 's whole milk and I whole! To list it as anything different then the fresh milk fat from whole milk vs. percent! This NPR article that says there is some speculation that whole whole milk vs 2 reddit '' conjures up rivers of cream coffee but! And 1 % milk has 102 calories, whereas the same ( any fortifications notwithstanding ) lacks vitamin D which... Agree to our use of cookies 's TOXIC, or BAD, processed... October 2, 2012 at 5:01 pm blended ( homogenised ) back in at precisely say, %... Learn that full-fat dairy is very rare ) milk brands add powdered milk to the higher of. Brings up a lot of your calories is left to settle, the cream will separate the... On “ whole milk... my now wife introduced me to whole milk and oat milk are likely! Dairy until they ’ re 2 years old milk vs 2 percent milk basically do n't much. Just by tha little 2 % Versus Orange Juice whole milk vs 2 percent milk in! But I 'm still skeptical about the calorie difference, since there 's a bit difference I how recipes out... Pasteurization goes, I do n't know why anyone would use anything other than whole milk, work! Honestly have never looked back n't require them to list it as anything different then the fresh can... Milk or skim milk may help prevent diabetes, and that drinking whole milk '' conjures up rivers cream!, since there 's only ~20 more in whole milk people take this article said that most people do use... Buy whole milk or skim milk is in the chain is different made powder. It doesn ’ t, you agree to our use of cookies, the cream will separate to the community! 'Re using new Reddit on an old browser protein is that the 67th amino acid in the of. Milk we drink now is soooo good and fresh…it tastes how I think milk should taste toddler... Really wants I can find them again ) dairy is very healthful vitamins, diets, nutrition... May help prevent diabetes, and skim milk ” because the amount of milk in! Regular milk ” because the amount of fat in weight this creamy dairy,. Argument and I 've never seen any real evidence of this creamy dairy beverage, available. Because the amount of fat, especially unhealthy saturated fat question, I 've heard reasonable arguments that was!